Blog / Roofers

Roofing Materials Compared: Shingles, Metal, Tile and More

· Roofers

Choosing a roofing material is one of the biggest decisions in a roof replacement. It affects how your home looks, how it handles weather, and how long the roof may last. There is no single right answer. This guide walks through common options and what to think about.

Asphalt shingles

Asphalt shingles are among the most common roofing materials on homes in the United States. They come in a range of colors and styles, and they are widely available, so many roofers know how to install them.

Good to know:

  • Many styles and quality levels.
  • Installers are easy to find.
  • Lifespan depends on the product, climate, and installation.
  • Heat, hail, and heavy wind can affect them.

Metal roofing

Metal roofs come as panels or as shingle-style pieces. They shed snow and rain well and can last a long time when installed properly.

Good to know:

  • Can be loud in rain unless the roof is built with sound-dampening layers.
  • Details such as fasteners and seams matter.
  • Different metals and finishes behave differently.
  • Installation takes specific skill, so ask about experience.

Clay and concrete tile

Tile is common in warm, dry regions. It is heavy and durable.

Good to know:

  • Your roof structure must be able to carry the weight. A structural check may be needed.
  • Tiles can crack if walked on.
  • Repairs require care.

Slate

Slate is a natural stone roofing with a classic look.

Good to know:

  • Very heavy, so structure matters.
  • Needs specialist installers.
  • Repairs require experience.

Wood shakes

Wood shakes give a natural appearance.

Good to know:

  • Need maintenance.
  • May be restricted in areas with wildfire risk. Check local codes and permits.

Flat and low-slope roofs

Flat roofs use different systems, such as membranes, rather than shingles. The right choice depends on the building and drainage. Ask a roofer who works on flat roofs often.

How to choose

Think through these questions:

  1. Climate. Do you face heavy snow, hail, wind, or intense sun?
  2. Home style. Does the look fit your home and neighborhood?
  3. Weight. Can your structure handle it?
  4. Rules. Does your city or HOA have restrictions? Some areas have fire-resistance rules or require certain materials.
  5. Time in the home. How long will you stay?
  6. Maintenance. How much work are you willing to do?
  7. Warranty. What do the maker and installer cover?

Costs vary widely by region, size and materials, so compare several offers.

Installation matters as much as the material

A good material installed poorly can fail early. Underlayment, flashing, ventilation, and fastening all play a role. Ask your roofer how they handle these details and whether they follow the manufacturer's installation instructions. Many manufacturer warranties depend on proper installation.

Ventilation and insulation

A roof works with your attic ventilation and insulation. Poor airflow can trap heat and moisture. Ask your roofer to look at ventilation as part of the job.

Ask to see samples and past work

Samples show how a material looks in daylight. Ask your roofer if they can show you completed jobs with the same material, or put you in touch with past customers who agree to talk. Look at the roof in different light, since color can change. Seeing the real thing helps you avoid surprises once the whole roof is finished.

Getting good offers on USTO PRO

When you post a request, describe your roof, its approximate age, and the problem you see. Add photos from the ground and, if you can reach it safely, from the attic. Do not climb onto the roof for photos. Local licensed roofers can send offers, and you can chat in the app to ask questions before you choose. Contact details stay hidden until a job is booked, and payment protection through held payments is available.

When to call a pro

Roofing is dangerous, and structural questions should be handled by qualified people. Use a licensed roofer, and ask about a structural review if you want a heavy material like tile or slate. Check local codes and permits before work starts.

To see what a roof job involves from start to finish, read how to prepare for a roof replacement. When offers arrive, our guide to comparing roofing estimates helps you sort them.

Browse pros at /services/roofers, or post a free request and tell us what material you are considering.

Get offers from local pros